
Pizza Toastie
For a lazy night in, try this quick and delicious pizza toastie stuffed with cheese and pepperoni.
Instructions
- 1
Top one piece of bread with marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese, and pepperoni.
- 2
Cover with a second piece of bread and butter both slices of bread from edge to edge.
- 3
Place in preheated toastie machine and cook until bread is golden brown. (If the toastie is not browning evenly, flip half way through).
- 4
Remove from toastie and slice in half.
- 5
Enjoy!
Recipe from tasty.co
Comments
Ingredients delivered in ~45 min
via Instacart from 1,400+ stores
Save it for next time
Ingredients (5)
- •2 slices white bread
- •2 tablespoons marinara sauce
- •½ cup mozzarella cheese
- •6 pieces pepperoni
- •2 tablespoons butter
Cook next with these ingredients
These recipes use most of what’s already in this cart.

One Whole Chicken, Three Different Meals
You’d also need: All Purpose Flour, Bunch Fresh Parsley, Bunch Lacinato Kale, Canola Oil +32 more

Meatball-Stuffed Garlic Bread
You’d also need: Baguette, Egg, Fresh Parsley, Garlic +3 more

Bacon Mac & Cheese-Stuffed Onion Rings
You’d also need: All Purpose Flour, Eggs, Freshly Ground Black Pepper, Garlic Powder +5 more

Chicken Parm-Stuffed Spaghetti Squash
You’d also need: Egg, Flour, Italian Seasoning, Oil +3 more